You set this up carefully. You had the conversations, you explained what your parent needed, you were told a carer would be matched to them, that companionship was part of the plan. And then you found out the carer left fifteen minutes before the scheduled time, but the log said they stayed the full hour.

That gap between what happened and what was recorded is not a small administrative hiccup. It is a breach of trust, and it sits right at the centre of something families feel but often struggle to name: you cannot be there every minute, and you are relying on the record to tell you the truth.

You are not being paranoid or difficult for finding this unacceptable.

A fifteen-minute shortfall might not sound dramatic. But if your parent is frail, elderly, and having a meal prepared as part of a care visit, that fifteen minutes is not dead time. It is part of what was promised. The care plan said companionship. A carer who is already mentally on their way to the next client is not providing companionship. And a record that does not reflect what actually happened means you cannot trust any future record either. That is the real problem.

What the record is supposed to do

Care companies that visit people at home are expected by the Care Quality Commission to keep accurate records of every visit, including arrival and departure times. The CQC's standards around safe care explicitly require that records reflect what actually happened, not what was scheduled. A log that is filled in based on the rota rather than actual departure time is not just a minor inaccuracy. It misrepresents the care that was delivered, and if your parent was paying for that hour and only received forty-five minutes, that is a billing issue on top of everything else.

The Homecare Association, which represents home care providers across the UK, publishes guidance saying families should receive transparent records of each visit. Most reputable companies now use electronic call monitoring, which timestamps arrival and departure via a mobile device at the property. If the company you are using has this system and the log still shows the wrong time, that is a more serious concern than a handwritten note filled in incorrectly.

What you can do tomorrow morning

The first thing to do is write down what you know, with dates and times, before anything else fades. If you were not there yourself, write down how you found out, who told you, and when. That paper trail matters if this goes further.

Then write to the care company, by email rather than phone, so there is a record. Be factual. State what you were told the visit schedule would be, what you understand to have happened, and that the log does not reflect the actual departure time. Ask them to explain the discrepancy. Ask what their call monitoring system records and request to see the raw data for that visit. You are entitled to ask. A well-run company will take this seriously and investigate. A company that becomes defensive or dismissive at this stage is telling you something important about what comes next.

If the response is inadequate, or if this turns out to be a pattern rather than a single incident, you have two escalation routes.

The first is the Care Quality Commission. If the care company is registered with the CQC, you can raise a concern at cqc.org.uk/give-feedback-on-care. The CQC does not investigate individual complaints on behalf of service users, but concerns about record-keeping and care delivery are exactly the kind of information they use when deciding whether to inspect or follow up with a provider. Your report may not change your situation overnight, but it goes on the record.

The second is the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman. If you are paying privately and have already complained to the company without a satisfactory outcome, the Ombudsman can investigate. They have real teeth and can make findings and recommend remedies.

For support while you are working through this, the Carers UK Helpline on 0808 808 7777 can help you think through what to say and what to expect. Age UK's Advice Line on 0800 678 1602 is also worth a call if you want someone with no commercial stake in the outcome to talk it through with you.

What good care actually looks like in any arrangement

Beyond this immediate situation, it is worth knowing what a well-structured care arrangement looks like, because that context helps you judge what you are dealing with.

In a good arrangement, you know which specific carer is going to your parent before each visit. Not a rota of different faces, not whoever is available. One person, consistently. You will have met them in person before any care began. There is a direct relationship between your family and that carer, rather than everything mediated through a coordination layer that does not always pick up on a Tuesday morning. And the carer keeps almost all of what you pay, which means they are not being squeezed to rush between five visits in an afternoon.

We at Hibant work this way. We are a London introductory care agency. When a family comes to us, we look across our carers, they choose the person they want, they meet them before anything is agreed, and the relationship is direct from there. We do not control visit logs on behalf of a rota. We cannot help you with the situation you are already in with another company, but if you are at the point of asking what a different kind of arrangement looks like, this is what it can look like.

What families in this situation often tell us is that the logging issue was the first sign of something, but not the only one. Patterns matter. Trust your read of the pattern.

Tonight

Send the email to the care company. Keep it factual and short. Ask for the call monitoring data for that visit. Give them a deadline, seven days is reasonable, to respond. You do not need to threaten anything yet. You just need it on record that you noticed, and you asked.

If you want to talk any of this through with someone before you write the email, the Carers UK Helpline is free and confidential: 0808 808 7777.

If you are also wondering what a steadier, more transparent arrangement might look like going forward, we would be glad to talk. We are a London introductory care agency. Every carer we introduce has been DBS-checked and insurance-verified, you meet them in person before any arrangement begins, and the relationship is between your family and that carer directly, so you know exactly who is walking through the door and when. You can reach us at hello@hibantcare.com or have a look at hibantcare.com.

Hibant

Useful links to keep handy

Looking for care or thinking of joining Hibant?

Whether you are a family navigating care for a loved one or a carer looking for fairer, more meaningful work, we would love to hear from you.

Find a carer Join as a carer
← Back to Understanding Care Questions? Get in touch