So many families tell us the same story. They rang around, they asked good questions, and then the agency said something warm and confident, something like: 'Don't worry, we have a brilliant team.' It felt like reassurance. It felt like the right answer. They signed up, the care started, and within a fortnight their parent had met seven different people, none of whom knew that they take their tea without milk, that the bathroom rail needs to be gripped on the left, or that they will refuse medication from anyone they do not recognise.

The phrase 'brilliant team' sounds good. The word 'team', though, is doing a lot of work in that sentence. And it is worth understanding exactly what it is covering for.

What 'a team' usually means in practice

In most agency models, a team is a pool. A rota. A list of people who are available on any given day to fill the slot in your parent's morning call. When someone on that list calls in sick, or takes annual leave, or moves to another client, another name from the pool steps in. This is not a failure of that agency. It is how the model is designed. The agency is selling coverage, not continuity. Coverage is a legitimate thing to sell. The problem is that nobody uses that word when they are trying to reassure a worried family.

According to Skills for Care, the home care sector in England has a turnover rate that regularly sits above thirty percent per year. That means roughly one in three carers leaves their role in any twelve-month period. In a pool of even eight or ten carers assigned to your parent, that number starts to feel very concrete, very quickly.

For someone living with dementia, this matters enormously. The Alzheimer's Society is clear that familiar faces, consistent routines, and reduced need to adapt to new people are not preferences. They are clinical factors that affect how distressed or settled a person is from one day to the next. A rotating cast of carers is not just inconvenient. For someone who can no longer reliably hold new information, it can be genuinely disorienting and frightening.

The questions that reveal the real picture

You are allowed to ask direct questions before you commit to any arrangement. The answers will tell you more than any marketing phrase. Try these:

A good arrangement, in any shape, has honest answers to all four. If the answer to the first question is 'it depends on the week', that is a real answer and you can weigh it. If the answer involves a reassuring phrase about the quality of the team without actually answering what you asked, that is the information you needed.

The Homecare Association publishes guidance on what families are entitled to expect when arranging home care. Continuity of carer is named explicitly as a quality marker. The Care Quality Commission, when it assesses providers, looks at whether the service responds to individual needs, which includes whether carers know the person they are visiting well enough to notice when something is different. A team of seven strangers rotating through cannot, by definition, notice that.

What good actually looks like

Good care, in any arrangement, has a small number of people. Ideally one, occasionally two if the hours require it. Those people are chosen with input from the family, not assigned by a coordinator. The family meets them before anything is agreed. The carer knows the person's history, preferences, and routines well enough that they can tell on a Tuesday that something is off, and ring someone to say so.

That is not a luxury. That is just what attentive care looks like when it is working. Continuity is the mechanism that makes everything else possible: trust, honest observation, dignity in the bathroom, the right cup of tea.

If you are in the middle of choosing care right now and something about the conversation with an agency feels vague, it is worth calling the Carers UK Helpline on 0808 808 7777 or Age UK on 0800 678 1602. Neither has a commercial stake in which arrangement you choose, and both can help you think through what your parent actually needs before you sign anything.

We at Hibant work as an introductory agency, which means the carer you meet is the carer who comes. You choose them yourself, you meet them in person before anything begins, and the day-to-day relationship is directly between your family and that one person. That is the model. Families who have come to us after a difficult run with rotating cover often say the same thing: they wish someone had told them to ask those four questions earlier.

If any of this feels relevant to what you are navigating right now, the most useful first step tonight is one phone call, either to Carers UK or to us. If you want to talk to us specifically, you can email hello@hibantcare.com or take a look at what we do at hibantcare.com. We are a small London introductory care agency, every carer we introduce has been DBS-checked and insurance-verified, and you meet them before any arrangement begins. No rotas. No pools. One person your parent can learn to recognise.

Hibant

Useful links to keep handy

Looking for care or thinking of joining Hibant?

Whether you are a family navigating care for a loved one or a carer looking for fairer, more meaningful work, we would love to hear from you.

Find a carer Join as a carer
← Back to Understanding Care Questions? Get in touch