You are paying fourteen hundred pounds a week, you have been through three carers in three months, and right now someone is living in your parents' home who is, at best, not great. The fridge has expired food in it. The freezing is being done wrong. These were in the care plan. You were promised careful matching. You were not expecting perfection. You were expecting someone to read the plan.

If that is where you are, please know that what you are feeling, that strange mixture of guilt and fury and sheer exhaustion, is entirely reasonable. You have not set your expectations too high. You have set your expectations at the level the agency told you to expect when they took your money.

The problem is not you. The problem is a structural one that affects a lot of live-in care arrangements, and it has a name: it is the gap between what gets promised during the sales conversation and what actually happens once the carer is placed. Understanding why it happens is the first step to doing something about it.

Why continuity breaks down so fast in live-in care

Live-in care is genuinely hard to staff. A carer living in someone else's home, sometimes in a rural or isolated setting, working long days, is under a particular kind of pressure that shifts in day care do not create. Isolation is the most common reason carers leave early. The second most common is that the placement was never quite right to begin with, because the matching process was driven by availability rather than fit.

Many agencies work from a pool of available carers and match primarily on timing. A family calls on a Thursday, they need cover by Monday, and the person with the right-sounding CV who is free that week gets placed. The family is told they have been carefully matched. What they have actually been given is the best available person at short notice. When that person leaves, the clock resets.

The Homecare Association, which represents home care providers across the UK, has published guidance making clear that continuity of carer is a marker of quality provision. When a provider cycles through three carers in twelve weeks, that is not a run of bad luck. It is a sign that something in the matching or support process needs examining.

What you can actually do this week

First, write a formal complaint to the agency. Not a phone call, a written complaint with a date on it. Document the three placements, the dates, the reasons given for each ending, and the specific care plan points that are not being followed now. Most agencies have a complaints procedure and are legally required to respond. If they are CQC-registered, a logged complaint creates a record. You can also raise a concern directly with the Care Quality Commission at cqc.org.uk. The CQC does not adjudicate individual disputes, but a pattern of placement failures and unmet care plans is exactly the kind of thing their inspectors look at when they assess a provider.

If you have gone through the agency's own complaints process and you are not satisfied with the outcome, the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman handles complaints about adult social care services. They are free to use and independent. Their website is at lgo.org.uk.

Second, ring the Age UK Advice Line on 0800 678 1602. They are free, they have no commercial stake in what you decide, and they can help you think through whether the current arrangement is salvageable or whether it is time to restructure it entirely. They have seen this situation many times.

Third, if the person in your parents' home right now is not following the care plan on food management and storage, that is not a minor irritation. Expired food and improper freezing are food safety issues for two elderly people, one of whom has mild Alzheimer's. It is reasonable to put that specific concern in writing to the agency today, and to ask what their supervision process is for checking that care plans are being followed.

What a better arrangement actually looks like

When live-in care works well, it tends to share a few features that are worth understanding, not because you should immediately go looking for something new, but because they give you a framework for what to push for wherever your parents' care comes from.

The family meets the carer in person before the arrangement begins, not just sees a CV. The carer's specific experience, including whether they have worked with dementia, whether they drive, whether they have managed household food routines, is discussed in a real conversation, not assumed from a profile. The family has a direct relationship with the carer, not just a relationship with a coordinator who then relays information. And when something is wrong, there is a straightforward way to raise it that does not feel like you are lodging a formal grievance against an institution.

At Hibant, we work as an introductory agency, which means we introduce families directly to individually vetted carers and then step back so the family and carer can build a real relationship. Every carer we introduce has been DBS-checked, insurance-verified, and reference-checked before they meet any family. Families in situations like yours, where continuity has broken down and trust has been worn thin, tell us the thing they most needed was to actually meet the person before they moved in.

Tonight

If there is one thing to do this evening, it is this: call the Carers UK Helpline on 0808 808 7777. They are open Monday to Friday and they will talk through the complaint process, your rights as a family paying for care, and what options look realistic for your parents' situation. You do not have to have a plan yet. You just have to make the call.

If you would rather talk through a different shape of arrangement, one where you meet the carer first and keep a direct relationship with them throughout, we are a London introductory care agency and this is exactly the kind of situation we exist to help with. Every carer we introduce is DBS-checked, insurance-verified, and reference-checked, and you meet them in person before any arrangement begins. You choose the person yourself. If that sounds like it might help, you can email us at hello@hibantcare.com or take a look at hibantcare.com.

Hibant

Useful links to keep handy

Looking for care or thinking of joining Hibant?

Whether you are a family navigating care for a loved one or a carer looking for fairer, more meaningful work, we would love to hear from you.

Find a carer Join as a carer
← Back to Understanding Care Questions? Get in touch